Looking at Shadows

I found the book, Gombrich, E.H. (2014), Shadows; The Depiction of Cast Shadows in Western Art. Yale University Press, very helpful in thinking about the placement and intensity of shadows. In particular, I liked a pair of very old quotations which made real sense to me:

Shadow: The darkness created by opaque bodies on the opposite side of the illuminated part.”

Shadow: In the language of painters it is generally understood to refer to the more or less dark colour which serves in painting to give relief to the representation by gradually becoming lighter. It is divided in three degrees called shadow, half-shadow and cast shadow. By shadow (ombra)is meant that which a body creates on itself, as for instance a sphere that has light on one part and gradually becomes half light and half dark, and that dark part is described as shadow (penumbra). Half-shadow (mezz’ombra)is called that area that is between light and the shadow through which one passes to the other, as we have said, gradually diminishing little by little according to the roundness of the object. Cast shadow(sbattimento)is the shadow that is caused on the ground or elsewhere by the depicted object….”

After Filippo Baldinucci, Vocabularia Toscano dell’Arte del Disegno, Florence 1681.

I know this is frightfully wordy and technical, but I hadn’t really thought before about the shape of an object causing its own shadow on itself, and then also being subject to the shadows cast upon it by other things. I have been consciously trying to think of this as “modelling shadow” and “cast shadow” when I have been sketching – as exemplified by the painting by Giovanni Battista Moroni – Portrait of a Gentleman with his Helmet on a Column Shaft, 1555-6.

            I shall continue to keep looking really carefully and drawing what I see, but it’s useful to have something which helps you to understand and analyse when you get to that part of a drawing where you have to look over and over to try and make sense of what you’re seeing.

Kleon, A. (2012). Steal Like an Artist. New York. Workman Publishing Ltd.

This is a great book, I read it in one sitting. It’ll be one to go back to when I’ve lost my way and can’t see the wood for the trees! I found the first few chapters particularly relevant to me, as it spelled out….well, I quote…”Your job is to collect good ideas. The more good ideas you collect, the more you can choose from to be influenced by.”

I liked the idea of finding out about an artist who interests me…and that leading me on to other artists, till I become part of a “family tree” of artists…I have already found this working out a bit with my research into Odilon Redon, in particular his use of tone to create atmosphere – am writing another blog post on this as we speak!

ODILON REDON

“(Bordeaux, 20 Apr. 1840; Paris, 6 July 1916).

French painter, draughtsman, and printmaker, one of the outstanding figures of Symbolism. He led a retiring life, first in his native Bordeaux, then from 1870 in Paris, and until he was in his fifties he worked almost exclusively in black and white—in charcoal drawings and lithographs. In these he developed a highly distinctive repertoire of weird subjects— strange amoeboid creatures, insects, and plants with human heads and so on, influenced by the writings of Edgar Allen Poe. He remained virtually unknown to the public until the publication of J. K. Huysmans’s celebrated novel A rebours in 1884: the book’s hero, a disenchanted aristocrat who lives in a private world of perverse delights, collects Redon’s drawings, and with his mention in this classic expression of decadence, Redon too became a figurehead of the movement.

During the 1890s he turned to painting and revealed remarkable powers as a colourist that had previously lain dormant. Much of his early life had been unhappy, but after undergoing a religious crisis in the early 1890s and a serious illness in 1894–5, he was transformed into a much more buoyant and cheerful personality, expressing himself in radiant colours in visionary subjects, flower paintings, and mythological scenes (the Chariot of Apollo was one of his favourite themes). He showed equal facility in oils and pastel and after 1900 he carried out a number of large decorative schemes. His flower pieces, in particular, were much admired by Matisse, and the Surrealists regarded Redon as one of their precursors. By the end of his life he was a distinguished figure, although still a very private person.”

Chilvers, I.Redon, Odilon.In  (Ed.), The Oxford Dictionary of Art and Artists.: Oxford University Press,. Retrieved 25 Mar. 2019, from http://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/acref/9780191782763.001.0001/acref-9780191782763-e-2041.

I have looked at a range of work by Redon, consulting in particular:

  • Bridgeman Education Library
  • Odilon Redon (1985), Galerie des Beaux-Arts (all in French!! – which has considerably tested my recall of schoolgirl French from over 40 years ago…)
  • Leeman, F (undated?): Odilon Redon and Emile Bernard – Masterpieces from the Andries Bonger Collection. Van Gogh Museum, Amsterdam; Wanders Publishers, Zwolle

His earlier work in particular shows very strong tonal contrasts, often placing a figure in half-light, before a dark shaded area adjacent to a bright feature, e.g.

Landscape, two figures, c.1880-1881, Van Gogh Museum, Amsterdam

La foret enchantee, 1870

Bordeaux, Musee des Beaux-Arts

The effect of the dark background in both these pictures imparts a slightly sinister feel – one is made to wonder what is hiding in the shadows.

He also did several pictures which seemed to be looking through a window, with a dark sombre interior contrasted with what seems a dazzling exterior – as if the gloom inside is in tension with the bright hope of the exterior. He also sets people against a window, making it appear as if they are ghostly,  trapped in some way inside.

Le Jour, 1891

Paris, Bibliotheque Nationale, Cabinet des Estampes

The thinker at the window, drawing in the style of Goya, 1878

Van Gogh Museum, Amsterdam

A review in Nineteenth-Century French Studies, Vol 42, Nos 1 & 2, Fall-Winter 2013-14 of an article by Dario Gamboni: The Brush and the Pen: Odilon Redon and Literature, draws attention to a remark by Gamboni about an unconscious slip in Redon’s early writings, where he puts “peine ombre” (meaning “sorrow shadow”) where he meant “penombre” (meaning twilight or darkness), and suggests that this slip reveals Redon’s painful associations with the shadows in his earlier works.

I made a small slideshow on the Bridgeman Education library with a couple more examples of the points above, plus one of his later flower paintings – even here he often uses dramatic contrasts in tone – this one has a very dark background, making the light tones of the yellow flowers positively “zing” with excitement. I made it public, so am hoping it can be seen at:

Slideshow created on March 25th at 6:15pm

Bridgeman Education Slideshow: Redon’s use of tone

A Pitcher of Flowers Redon, Odilon (1840-1916)

Primitive Man, 1872 (charcoal, black chalk, stumping, wiping & erasing, with white & ochre gouache on paper)

Redon, Odilon (1840-1916)

Lumiere, 1893 (litho) Redon, Odilon (1840-1916)

Life drawing class led by Scott Russell at Tavistock Group of Artists, 18.3.19

Scott Russell has worked as an artist in Tavistock for several years; he runs a number of life drawing classes which colleagues at the art group have attended and recommended. His work can be seen at https://cargo-collective.com/scottrussell/About-Scott-Russell.

            He began by demonstrating how to tackle a life picture in oils, but members were free to use any media they like, and of course, I chose drawing. He gave several useful tips on (a) oil painting, and (b) placement within the drawing of features and body parts (e.g. corner of mouth leads up to centre of eye) – see notes in A3 sketchbook for this.

            Two particular things apart from that that I wanted to record here:

(i)  Scott is someone who likes to get over the fear of a blank page by big, sweeping movements, and has some words of advice about freeing up:

  • Failure is a part of the process
  • Let the viewer do some work – makes it more interesting for them
  • Relax and paint how you want to paint
  • Push yourself – surprise yourself – discover
  • Look back at the subject for clues all the time – it’s like a detective game

(ii)  Talking to another member, they recommended watching and working through RA online life drawing classes – NEED TO DO!

Downs et al: Drawing Now – Between the lines of contemporary art (2007, I.B. Tauris)

Random observations:

  • The back cover of the book sent me to the online peer-reviewed journal, TRACEY (lboro.ac.uk) where I browsed some sketchbooks, amongst which was that of Susan Kemenyffy (January 2010). I am currently working on basic shapes and have been trying to make my lines clearer as I’m aware they can be a bit scrappy and overlapping; however, I was drawn to several images in her sketchbooks (e.g. the monument in sketchbook 4) which is drawn with very scrappy lines and yet has, to my eyes, great energy. I am going to keep going with my attempts to make my lines clearer, but will also continue to experiment with my existing default drawing style but try to infuse it with a similar energy.   

The Creative Licence by Danny Gregory (2006 – pub, Hyperion – www.hyperionbooks.com)

I have come to this course later in life than many; I have found this book supportive and inspiring on various levels: first, the determination of the author, expressed and demonstrated with considerable energy, that there is no reason why anyone could not draw at some point every day; second, the number of motivational quotes it contains, amongst which are:

  • “It is never too late to be what you might have been” – George Eliot
  • “Drawing…(makes you)…pay attention in a way you normally wouldn’t…Every line, page, brick, unit of the thing you draw becomes essential. You’re looking to catch each component in order to understand the construction of the object and therefore realise the beauty of its balance, the necessity of each small part.” – Patti Lynn Gregory **(this chimes with what I wrote yesterday about the observational skills of James Lewis – see notes on his demonstration)
  • “I cannot tell you how happy I am to have taken up drawing again. I’ve been thinking of it, but I always considered the thing impossible and beyond my reach” – Vincent van Gogh in a letter to his brother
  • “It is only by drawing often, drawing everything, drawing incessantly, that one fine day you discover to your surprise that you have rendered something in its true character” – Camille Pissarro
  • “Ironically, our society tends to portray artists as dreamers. But those who suppress their creativity are actually the ones living in a dream. An artist is someone who sees and feels reality very intensely” – Danny Gregory

So, having been duly inspired, I am off to do some drawing in my sketchbook…

13.3.19 – Demonstration by James Lewis – Seascapes in acrylic – West Devon Art Group

  • His website is at www.jameslewisart.co.uk
  • He is self-taught – he started by looking at the paintings of local artist Alan Kingwell – see www.alankingwell.co.uk– and copying them. By doing this he learned how to create an image, and he gradually developed his own style. 
  • He looks to convey movement and light
  • See A5 sketchbook 1 for detailed notes on colours and techniques used

Demonstration image created:

The thing which struck me most about his demonstration was the care and hours he has clearly spent in observing a difficult subject, moving water. He did not paint from a reference photo; it came out of his head onto a blank canvas. He was very clear on how he wanted colour gradations, light direction and shadow and highlights. I know I am very reliant at the moment on having an object, person or scene in front of me from which to draw – I need to work a lot more on looking around me more carefully and analyse what I am seeing so that I can generalise and hence invent realistically as he has.

11.3.19 – Talk and demonstration by Katy Choroszewska at Tavistock Group of Artists “Use of dyes and colour wheel in art”

Katy began with a brief history of colour.

  • Until the 17thcentury, there was a 4-colour theory from which all other colours were allegedly derived: black, white, red and yellow (no blue) – this fell in with the pattern of the times where lots of things were supposed to go in fours e.g. the humours.
  • In 1664 the scientist Robert Boyle wrote his “Experiments and Considerations Touching Colours”, which said that the 5 basic colours were black, white, red, blue and yellow
  • “Werner’s Nomenclature of Colour” (current edition 2018, pub by Natural History Museum) was handed round – the original edition (1814) was taken by Darwin on the Beagle to help him with identification of exact hues on the animals and plants he found
  • Colours have been demonstrated to affect our mood. An experiment by Baker and Miller (in charge of a prison in Seattle) was carried out, whereby they painted a holding cell in the prison in pink and found that violence disappeared – this became known as Baker-Miller Pink.
  • In the late 18thcentury, Indian yellow became available. In 1883, Joseph Hooker investigated its origins, and found out that it was basically boiled urine of cows from Bengal who were fed on mango leaves.
  • Ultramarine blue was originally made from lapis lazuli from Afghanistan, and was very expensive. People began to use a cheaper alternative – smot- made from cobalt ground glass – but this was less good as it eventually fades to an orangey-yellow.
  • In 1512, the colour orange stopped being called yellow-red with the advent of actual oranges from abroad.
  • Purple was produced from rotting shellfish – it was a long process and therefore very expensive.
  • In 1853, about half of hospital admissions were for ague; the treatment for this was quinine, but again, this was very expensive, and a Professor von Hoffman set his student, William Perkin, to find a cheaper alternative. He researched with coal tar, and unexpectedly ended up with a flask of bright purple liquid (aniline dye) – this was the first synthetic dye.
  • Brown dye appeared on the market from Egypt – called Mummy (literally….)
  • The blackest manufactured black is Vantablack (developed by Surrey NanoSystems in the UK), absorbing 99.96% of visible light. It is not readily available, however, as it has been licensed to Anish Kapoor.

Katy went on to demonstrate the dyeing process she uses (with Procion MX dyes in an alkaline environment created by soda-ash).

She had made the point beforehand that it matters which hues you choose when mixing colours, and went on to create a very pleasing colour wheel by mixing magenta, cerulean and lemon yellow in various proportions.

She dyes fabrics and thread, both of which she sells, and belong to the Embroiderers’ Guild – she is currently involved in designing and creating works for the National Trust depicting the history of Cotehele House in Cornwall.

Tutor conversation, Rachel Forster, 8.3.19

  • Be honest and think WHY? – my opinion, and explaining why I think it, is the important bit to get down
  • WordPress blogs – Rachel will send an example from another student whose blog she feels is well done. When I have got my blog up and running, send Rachel the link so she can keep an eye on it.
  • Writing up research should NOT sound like an exhibition catalogue. I should think and write about how the research links to MY work – e.g. I said I enjoyed the Egon Schiele exhibition – so, what exactly is there about it that I like and how will I respond to it – how can I use it in my work?
  • Sketch REGULARLY – show what’s going in in my head
  • Get into the habit of regularly collecting reference images
  • Rachel will send a list of books for research
  • When I submit work for assessment, if I especially want feedback on a specific part of the work, it is OK to say so
  • KEEP REFERRING BACK TO THE ASSESSMENT CRITERIA – measure myself against them
  • ASSIGNMENT 1 TO BE IN BY 31ST MAY
  • Reference to “Contextual” – how do I react to it? Why? What will I do with/about it?